Against the Bears, the Broncos flunked the midterm and aced the final

Oct 3, 2023, 10:09 PM | Updated: Oct 4, 2023, 2:43 am

Marvin Mims Jr....

(Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)

(Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)

For the better part of three quarters in Chicago last Sunday, it looked as if the Broncos were headed for another poor day.

Oh, maybe not to the degree of last week, which resulted in a desperate long-time chronicler of the team’s travails seeking out a new grading scale that went down to “Z” to describe a defensive performance that was, by multiple standards, the worst for any NFL team since the Johnson administration. (Fortunately, it was Lyndon — not Andrew.)

But the Broncos might have ended up with Fs across the board if matters had worsened after falling behind 28-7. Instead, the Broncos had their biggest comeback win in nearly 11 years.

The Broncos ultimately put out the fire. But how much credit do they deserve — when in many ways, they lit the match themselves with self-inflicted wounds?



After three weeks of describing second-half fades, this time the Broncos surged after halftime — although once again, they did roar to a first-quarter touchdown, showing that their touch on openers remains magical.

The offense also averaged 3.0 points per non-kneeldown possession. It’s the third time in four games that the Broncos have reached at least 3 PPP. That will put you where you want to be more often than not.

But five false starts in a game? That is unsustainable and shows that plenty of little things need to be fixed.


Russell Wilson is on point. The protection was improved from previous weeks, and it looks as if the offensive line is finding its form — after the snap, of course.

The Broncos need to find more opportunities for Marvin Mims Jr. The 17 snaps he played Sunday were a season- and career-high for the rookie. But that still represents just 35 percent of the possible repetitions. Brandon Johnson also checked in at that percentage, and he caught his second touchdown pass of the season.


Cecil Lammey and I have been telling y’all about Jaleel McLaughlin for months. Shoot, I asked Payton about the Youngstown State product early in camp, before the true picture began to emerge. He processes preternaturally; his vision becomes reaction in a split-second. But he’s also learning how to be patient when the moment requires it.

Javonte Williams and Samaje Perine were minimal factors; they combined for 12 yards on 8 carries, with Williams limited because of a hip pointer.



So here is the conundrum of such an exercise: Does one solid quarter of work outweigh the previous three substandard ones? And, specifically, do a handful of plays in the final 15 minutes make up for the failures that preceded them — and even some stretches in the fourth quarter where the Bears knifed through the Broncos?

Not entirely, but enough to earn a passing grade here. First of all, the Broncos’ success equation on defense might rely upon explosive plays to compensate for what appears to a problematic situation developing at the line of scrimmage, where the Broncos have been dominated in recent weeks.


Two plays redeemed the day, of course — Nik Bonitto’s sack-fumble of Justin Fields that resulted in Jonathon Cooper’s scoop-and-score, and then Kareem Jackson’s game-sealing interception. In between, D.J. Jones forced an intentional-grounding penalty which short-circuited the Bears final drive.

Ja’Quan McMillian didn’t represent a clear upgrade on Essang Bassey as he moved up to the nickel corner position, although his tackling was better. Meanwhile, teams continue to pick at Damarri Mathis. Four receptions came in his direction — the only four times he was targeted.

But there were too many open pass catchers throughout the game. Coverage busts were too frequent, including on Cole Kmet’s 22-yard touchdown catch in the second quarter, when he basically had an area the size of Millennium Park in which to catch Fields’ pass.


Here is where a justifiable concern remains. Denver’s front seven continues to struggle in this phase, while missed tackles are present at all three levels. Chicago’s running backs averaged over 5 yards per carry, and too many times were untouched racing through wide holes.



The muffed kickoff return by Marvin Mims Jr. marred the day and kept the grade down. Riley Dixon was just OK; his hang times were decent and he dropped two punts inside the 20-yard line, but the placement and distance could have been better.

Wil Lutz was perfect, however. He hasn’t missed a placekick in the last three games. He appears to be back to his pre-injury form.


Postgame Grades


Andrew Mason

The Broncos passing game will look to fix myriad issues

It was a week to forget for the Broncos, whose inconsistency helped lead to their first loss since Oct. 12 at Kansas City.

5 days ago

Javonte Williams...

Andrew Mason

Javonte Williams, Broncos ground game have something good cooking

Javonte Williams showed burst against the Browns as the Broncos' run game continues to be among the NFL's most efficient.

13 days ago

Sean Payton...

Andrew Mason

For Broncos, avoiding big mistakes was enough in Week 11

Sean Payton wasn't entirely pleased with the Broncos performance in Week 11 -- and indeed, there was plenty to scrutinize from the win.

20 days ago


Andrew Mason

The Broncos don’t work without the ‘third phase’ being first-rate

Yeah, the Broncos were bailed out, and PATs were an adventure, but the special teams still comes up big time after time.

25 days ago


Andrew Mason

Broncos defense: From zeroes to heroes in a month

There wasn't a grade low enough for the Broncos defense earlier in this season. Oh, how a month can change things.

1 month ago

Fabian Moreau...

Andrew Mason

Fabian Moreau makes the grade as he assumes larger role

Fabian Moreau made his first Broncos start on Sunday, and with performances like the one had, he could stay in the lineup a while.

2 months ago

Against the Bears, the Broncos flunked the midterm and aced the final