ADVERTISEMENT
September 12th, 2026

If you had to pick one Broncos coach to win a single game, do you pick Sean Payton or Mike Shanahan?

On The Fan Weekends, Kyle Reece and Marcello Romano tackle a fascinating question: Which former Broncos coach would you pick to win a single NFL game — Mike Shanahan or Sean Payton?

The guys debate the strengths, legacies, and styles of both coaches, breaking down what makes Shanahan’s steady hand and Payton’s aggressive approach so compelling. Which coach would you trust most in a one‑game scenario, and what does that choice say about the Broncos’ identity as a franchise?

This is the full breakdown of coaching greatness, Denver’s history, and the tension of choosing between two proven winners.


Kyle and Cello debate Shanahan vs Payton

What makes Shanahan’s legacy unique in Denver

Comparing their strengths in a one‑game scenario

What the debate says about Broncos history and future

Fan perspectives on which coach they’d trust most


Broncos Country — weigh in:
• Who would you trust in a one‑game scenario, Shanahan or Payton
• What makes your pick the right choice
• And what does this debate reveal about the Broncos’ coaching legacy

Denver Broncos

Nfl