How should the Broncos split carries between J.K. Dobbins and Jonah Coleman?

Sean Payton wants two running backs. The Denver Broncos’ backfield has been picked apart by injuries, so supplying them is harder than it sounds.

On a recent episode of “Orange and Blue Today,” Cecil Lammey and Andrew Mason spent a good stretch of their Panthers preview on who should get the carries. Lammey answer started with a preference for Jonah Coleman. Mason’s started with the roster.

The case for the hot back

Lammey wants Coleman to build on the progress he showed against the Chiefs, and he’d like that to mean a heavy workload. He said he’d heard the plan against Kansas City was to lean on J.K. Dobbins, but after Dobbins lost eight yards and Coleman “popped,” Denver rode the hot hand.

Lammey isn’t sold on that approach.

“I personally don’t like hot hand,” Lammey said.

His reason is the juice people around the team keep ascribing to Coleman. That’s why he sees Coleman as a closer, the back you want with a lead and a few minutes left.

The case for the depth chart

Mason agreed Coleman is performing better. But he said the Broncos can’t afford to freeze Dobbins out, and his evidence was a list of injuries.

“Jonah’s already been on IR this year,” Mason said. R.J. Harvey and Tyler Badie are on injured reserve too. Dobbins, for all his injury history, is the one who has played all eight games, and Denver has already used its entire room, down to Cody Schrader off the practice squad.

A trade doesn’t solve it either. Mason said there’s no guarantee a deal happens or that anything palatable is out there, and a Jonathan Taylor deal might be too rich for the Broncos.

“You don’t know that you’re going to have another running back on the roster next Tuesday,” Mason said.

Dobbins isn’t what he was

Mason made the case without flattering Dobbins. He called him less productive and less explosive than last year’s version, and said he dances too much.

“This isn’t the same running back that the Broncos saw last year for those 10 games,” Mason said.

Lammey attributed part of the change to the Lisfranc injury. Mason added that run blocking has dipped this year, though it improved over the past couple of games. He said a healthy Dobbins would be averaging north of 4 yards a carry.

Where they landed

The two met in the middle, and the compromise is about timing. Lammey conceded Dobbins has to play, then asked for a sequence.

“I would prefer J.K. get used early so that Jonah can close late,” Lammey said.

Carolina’s new look might widen that window. The Panthers fired their defensive coordinator and moved to Todd Wash, and Mason said the indication is they’ll be more aggressive. In his view, that could open chances for Coleman if the blockers hold up, and for Bo Nix if he handles the pressure.

Lammey’s counter to blitzes is to keep running. Chunk gains turn third-and-7 into third-and-2.

The question comes down to whether a team can run its best back and its most available back at once. For this week, the hosts say it can, by giving each a different part of the game.

Disclosure: This article was transcribed from our original audio content and edited for readability with the assistance of generative AI. The article has been reviewed by our editorial team prior to publication. Please watch or listen to the clip above for the full segment.

Related

Broncos won’t have Brandon Jones, two other key defensive players in CarolinaVance Joseph calls Alex Singleton the best linebacker in the NFLSean Payton says he and Bo Nix will ‘ditch the plays that neither of us love’Courtland Sutton should be getting more looks in the red zoneContenders, including the Broncos, may skip the big splash at the deadlineIs Bo Nix’s rebound enough for the Broncos to make a big trade?