Broncos, despite being short-handed, let a golden chance vanish into the snow

DENVER — My dad often said, “The saddest thing in life is a missed opportunity.”

And even with their starting quarterback, leading rusher and second-leading wide receiver left watching helplessly Sunday, what vanished into the snow-strangled afternoon was an opportunity lost for the Denver Broncos, one that will not be easily regained.

The failed fourth-and-1 in the second quarter looms largest in what proved to be a 10-7 loss, not only because of the eventual defeat margin, but because of what Sean Payton knew was coming: a second-half snowstorm.

Maybe he and the Broncos didn’t know the degree to which snow would blanket Empower Field at Mile High, but given that the pregame press-box announcement called for one inch of snow to fall during the second half of play, you didn’t need to be Jim Cantore to know that an accumulation substantial enough to affect play was coming.

You take that, mix in a defense already appearing to be at hurricane strength, add in trying to get by with a backup quarterback and factor in a New England Patriots team with a quarterback playing his first postseason road game, and you have a formula made for a conservative call.

Take the Patriots and Drake Maye, who to that point had led three drives that netted 12 yards and a single first down: Teams with quarterbacks in their first postseason road starts entered Sunday 59-119 since the 1970 AFL-NFL merger.

Maye appears on the path to joining the NFL’s elite echelon of quarterbacks no matter what Sunday’s result had been, but at that moment, his short-term destiny appeared the same as all-timers such as Peyton Manning, Kurt Warner, Terry Bradshaw, Joe Montana, Steve Young and Drew Brees. They all lost their first postseason road games.

Some, like Warner, were downright awful; he threw three interceptions and lost a fumble the first time he went on the road for a playoff game.

So, a 10-0 lead with a historical trend that’s two-thirds in your favor? And the chance to give your understudy quarterback a two-score lead, while providing your defense license to pin its ears back and attack Maye with impunity? Along with the afore-mentioned snowstorm?

Cripes, even the win-probability added computer gods said, “Kick,” giving the Broncos a two-percentage-point edge on attempting the field goal rather than going for it.

—> NE (0) @ DEN (7) <—
DEN has 4th & 1 at the NE 14, Q2 09:28

Recommendation (MEDIUM): 👟🏈 Field goal attempt (+2.1 WP)
Actual play: 👉 J.Stidham pass incomplete short right to R.Harvey (C.Woodson) [M.Williams]. pic.twitter.com/qKNwHdqb8V

— 4th down decision bot (@ben_bot_baldwin) January 25, 2026

Alas …

“Yes, it just felt like we had momentum to get up 14. It felt like we had a good call,” Payton said.

“… Yes, I think the feeling was, ‘Man, let’s be aggressive.’ To get up 14, I was just watching the way our defense was playing. Look the turnover on our end resulting in a touchdown, and outside of that, I thought we did a good job in containing them.”

But even a great defense could use a margin for error over the course of 60 minutes.

A field goal doesn’t dull momentum, especially when it increases the edge from one score to two — a deficit rarely faced by the 2025 Patriots, who trailed by two scores in just three games this season, losing two of them.

And when Stidham’s Cinderella story turned into a pumpkin under pressure from Christian Elliss, haphazardly pushing the ball backwards instead of eating it for the sack and allowing All-Rookie punter Jeremy Crawshaw to blast another one of his boomers downfield,

“There’s always regrets,” Payton said. “… Yeah, there will always be second thoughts.”

It’s the sort of decision that creates another decision that leaves dozens of pints of ice cream emptied: Darkest Chocolate, Frosé, Brambleberry Crisp? Sweet Cream Biscuits and Peach Jam?

Any would do. None will erase the sour taste.

THE GAME WASN’T THE SAME FOR THE BRONCOS AFTER THE FOURTH-DOWN FAILURE

It was the pivot point: unmistakable, undeniable.

When the fourth down failed, the Broncos walked off the field with eight first downs and an average of 4.8 yards per play; New England had just one first down and 1.0 yards per snap. For the rest of the game, the numbers nearly inverted; the Broncos had just 1.7 yards per play and three first downs; the Patriots 3.8 yards per snap and 11 first downs.

The snow didn’t help matters, but the Patriots found a bit more footing. The Broncos found three-and-outs; four of their five series after halftime ended without a first down. Their chance at a game-tying field goal with 4:42 left in the game came only because a shanked punt gave them possession at the New England 32-yard line.

And with that, the Broncos found themselves on the wrong side of the 50 percent of top-seeded teams since the playoff expansion to 14 who make it to the Super Bowl. Seattle and Denver ensured that trend continued; the Broncos were on the business end of it.

Now the climb starts again.

“It’s especially tough because you have zero idea if you’ll ever be back in an AFC Championship Game. That’s a fact. Like, you’ll have zero idea if you’ll ever make a Super Bowl; that’s a fact. You never know,” tight end Adam Trautman said.

“So, yeah, to get home-field advantage, first-round bye and just not being able to finish and get to the Super Bowl, it sucks and it hurts and you see it on guys’ faces, and that’s how you know you’re built the right way, though, is that everyone’s [ticked] off about it, not happy about it.”

The anger is there.

But the worst part of it is this: The game was in the Broncos’ hands. They could taste victory. But they didn’t take the sensible bite, and ultimately they gagged away the best opportunity they might have for a while.

Related

Broncos star CB Pat Surtain II again voted a top-10 player in the NFLIn Broncos loss, they got a win in something specific that truly matteredBo Nix happy with ‘solid’ first TD drive, says return ‘was like riding a bike’Sean Payton unhappy after Packers demolish Broncos, sends message to startersBroncos waste no time getting Jaylen Waddle involved in his preseason debutBo Nix throws a TD, leads two scoring drives in return from broken ankle