NHL execs and players rank Cale Makar league’s top defenseman

Feb 13, 2024, 4:20 PM

Colorado Avalanche superstar Cale Makar is the best defenseman in the world.

We already knew that, but for a second year in a row, so does the rest of the NHL.

Makar was voted the league’s top defenseman by executives and players in a new survey released by ESPN on Tuesday. He was ranked first on 17 of the 20 ballots and second on the other three. Those first-place votes went to Vancouver defenseman Quinn Hughes, who finished second on the top-10 list.

He’s essentially “Connor McDavid, except a defenseman,” one responder told ESPN’s Greg Wyshynski. That’s high praise, considering the Oilers star McDavid has won the Hart Trophy as the NHL’s MVP three times in his career and two of the last three seasons.

As ESPN points out, Makar has tallied the most points for a defenseman since he entered the league full-time in the 2019-2020 season. He has 306 points in just 286 games, or more than one per contest. Makar has 60 points in 48 games this year (13 goals, 47 assists), which trails only Hughes (65 points) among defenseman. He was an All-Star once again and even won the NHL’s hardest shot at the festivities in Toronto.

And while Makar’s line-mate Devon Toews didn’t crack the top-10, he did finish No. 13 in the survey. Essentially these voters think the Avalanche have two of the 13 best defenseman in the league.

Cale Makar will look to win the Norris Trophy for a second time in his career as the NHL’s best defenseman. He’s been nominated three years in a row and won the award in 2021-2022, the same year the Avs took home their third Stanley Cup.

To check out the complete defenseman rankings, click here.


Alexandar Georgiev...

Will Petersen

Alexandar Georgiev shouldn’t play another game for the Avalanche

If Justus Annunen is still sick, it's time to switch to Ivan Prosvetov; if he has an NHL jersey, he can't be worse than Alexandar Georgiev

48 minutes ago


Rachel Vigil

What went wrong for the Avalanche against the Jets?

Mike Evans reacts to the shocking loss against the Winnipeg Jets and takes a look at what elements of the team, such as the Avs' goaltending, are to blame for their loss.

9 hours ago

Alexandar Georgiev...

Will Petersen

Alexandar Georgiev has another bad night, Avalanche lose Game 1

Avalanche goalie Alexandar Georgiev gave up four goals on the first 10 shots of the game he faced on Sunday, and things didn't get better

1 day ago

Jonathan Drouin Avalanche Jets...

Will Petersen

Ahead of the Jets series, Avalanche get absolutely brutal news

The team announced that forward Jonathan Drouin will miss the entire Round 1 Avalanche and Jets series with a "lower-body injury"

3 days ago

Pavel Francouz...

Will Petersen

Avs Stanley Cup hero Pavel Francouz officially calls it a career

Pavel Francouz was awesome for the Avalanche in the 2022 playoffs, relieving starter Darcy Kuemper after he suffered a nasty eye injury

4 days ago

Avalanche Jets schedule...

Will Petersen

Here’s the full schedule for the Avalanche and Jets in the first round

When do you need to be locked into your TV or headed downtown to catch the game? Here's the schedule between the Avalanche and Jets

4 days ago

NHL execs and players rank Cale Makar league’s top defenseman