Explaining why the Broncos should go all in on tanking this season

Oct 20, 2023, 6:13 AM | Updated: 9:27 am

Ever since the Broncos lost to Washington in Week 2, I’ve been calling for the Broncos to tank. While more and more fans and media have jumped on that bandwagon over subsequent weeks, there is still a vocal (minority?) of Broncos Country who believes that is a terrible idea. It reached a crescendo this week during my show with Stink when a listener sent me this terse text:

“Mike Evans has a loser mentality.”

Let me take this time to explain why I want the Broncos to tank. It has nothing to do with having a loser mentality. It has everything to do with what is the reality of the Broncos’ situation.

Simply put, the eight years of slapping band-aids on the problem has got to stop. There needs to be an understanding that it’s time to strip this thing down to the studs and rebuild.

When I suggest tanking, I don’t mean I want the players to go out and try to lose. I expect them to be professionals and try their best. Tanking comes from the front office in the forms of trading off players for draft picks, stashing players on season-ending injured reserve and cutting back veterans’ playing time to give younger players a longer look.

I hadn’t thought about the coaches being involved in the tanking process until I recently heard Philip Lindsay suggest Sean Payton was setting Russell Wilson up to fail with some of his play calling. While my more reasonable half chalks this up to poor coaching, the little devil perched on my shoulder wouldn’t necessarily mind if this was being done intentionally.

So why do I want the Broncos to lose? The answer is they need better players and finishing with as high a first-round pick as possible is the best path to getting a great player.

If that pick can be in the top two and it would allow the Broncos to get, in the words of Joel Klatt, a “generational” QB like Caleb Williams or Drake Maye, then let’s do it. If it means picking somewhere between No. 3 and 5 in the first round and being able to snare a stud left tackle, then sign me up.

Please don’t try and tell me losing isn’t beneficial. Take a look at the way the Avalanche’s Stanley Cup-winning core was built.

In 2011, the Avs had just 68 points and missed the playoffs. They drafted Gabe Landeskog at No. 2 overall. In 2013, they finished with 39 points in a shortened season and missed the playoffs. They drafted Nathan MacKinnon with the No. 1 overall pick. In 2015, they missed the playoffs yet again and drafted Mikko Rantanen at No. 10 overall. Finally in 2017, they stumbled home with a franchise worst 48 points. Their consolation prize? Cale Makar with the fourth-overall pick.

Moral of the story? Please don’t tell me losing big can’t pay off in the long run.


Drop the Mike

Jared Bednar...

Mike Evans

Do back-to-back wins mean the Avs have escaped the doldrums?

An 8-2 loss to the Blues still stings, but wins over the Kraken and Ducks show that the Avalanche know how to respond to adversity

6 months ago

Jamal Murray of the Denver Nuggets...

Mike Evans

Championship swagger, a costly gamble and Nuggets nuggets

The Nuggets have come out of the gates looking like a team on a mission, Jamal Murray's injury is costly in more ways than one, and more

7 months ago

Russell Wilson...

Mike Evans

The Broncos can’t move forward with Russell Wilson after this season

When experts watch the Broncos game film, they come to the conclusion that Denver's quarterback isn't doing the things he needs to do

7 months ago

Artturi Lehkonen #62, Ryan Johansen #12, Jonathan Drouin #27 and Cale Makar #8...

Mike Evans

Hungry Avs ready to reclaim Cup after last season’s disappointment

After getting bounced in the first round a season ago, the Avalanche made some roster tweaks they hope will get them back to title form

8 months ago

Davante Adams, Denver...

Mike Evans

Broncos facing a must-win in season opener against the Raiders

In his debut as the Broncos head coach, Sean Payton knows the importance of getting off to a good start and building some momentum

9 months ago

Coach Prime Deion Sanders class...

Mike Evans

With week one looming, are the Buffs actually ready for Prime Time?

After an offseason unlike any other, the Colorado football program finally has to play games, with the hype train barreling down on them

9 months ago

Explaining why the Broncos should go all in on tanking this season