Report: “Don’t expect a suspension” after Avs’ Cale Makar takes a nasty hit

Feb 8, 2023, 11:12 AM

Cale Makar...

(Photo by Jeanine Leech/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

(Photo by Jeanine Leech/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

The Avalanche lost to the Penguins 2-1 in overtime on Tuesday night.

That result was lousy enough, as Colorado blew a 1-0 lead late in the third period then couldn’t convert on a rare 4-on-3 power-play in OT before Pittsburgh ultimately won it.

But something else that happened in the game was a bigger story, and it appears Avs’ defenseman Cale Makar won’t be getting any justice.

Early in the third period, Makar took a nasty blindside hit from Penguins center Jeff Carter. He briefly went down on the ice and then had to go down the tunnel and back to the Colorado locker room. Luckily, he’d return to the game, but that doesn’t make this less difficult to watch.

After the game, head coach Jared Bednar was blunt about what he saw, while the referees seemed to give Makar a fairly questionable explanation for why no penalty was called.

“Pretty blindside,” Makar told Peter Baugh of The Athletic. “The ref said apparently we ran into each other, but I don’t know how that’s possible. He was coming down the ice.”

And this is where it gets even more frustrating. On Wednesday morning, Baugh reported the NHL Department of Player Safety reviewed the hit and likely won’t be suspending Carter.

You can watch that video 100 times, and it is indeed a collision. But it’s a collision that Carter initiates with a blindside hit. It absolutely should’ve been a penalty during the game, and now it should be at least a fine, and probably a suspension for Carter.

It sounds like neither of those will happen, which is unfortunate. The only piece of good news is Makar appears to be okay, but that doesn’t mean what Carter did is acceptable. Or that the next player he does that against will walk away unscathed.



Andrew Cogliano...

Will Petersen

A few weeks after fracturing his neck, Andrew Cogliano goes to Nuggets game

It's a great sign that Cogliano was out and about, after he missed the Avalanche's Game 7 loss thanks to the horrific injury on a very sketchy hit

14 days ago

Gabriel Landeskog...

Will Petersen

A day after surgery, Avs captain Gabriel Landeskog posts positive update

We'll see if Landeskog can ever be the same player again, or even get on the ice at all, but it looks like the captain is taking everything in stride

21 days ago

Gabriel Landeskog Valeri Nichushkin...

Mike Evans

The Avalanche face huge uncertainty heading into offseason

With two key players becoming huge question marks and a farm system that hasn't produced of late, Colorado might become a one-hit wonder

22 days ago

Chris MacFarland...

Will Petersen

Avalanche stay vague, but management takes first questions on Nichushkin

The forward signed a $49 million contract last offseason, and GM Chris MacFarland confirmed he would like him on the team moving forward

24 days ago

Gabriel Landeskog...

Will Petersen

Avs say Landeskog will undergo another knee surgery, out for 2023-2024

Landeskog's played 20 hockey games the last 14 months, but they were important ones; those 20 helped the Avs capture their third Stanley Cup

24 days ago

Valeri Nichushkin...

Will Petersen

Seattle Times obtains 911 call surrounding incident at Avs team hotel

In the 911 call, an unidentified man told dispatchers "we suspect someone might have OD’d on alcohol potentially or something got mixed in a drink"

29 days ago

Report: “Don’t expect a suspension” after Avs’ Cale Makar takes a nasty hit