Should the Broncos play their starters in the preseason finale?

The Denver Broncos close out their preseason schedule on Friday night against the Minnesota Vikings, and the conversation surrounding the game has very little to do with the Vikings. It has everything to do with what happens on the Denver sideline, specifically, which players are standing on it in street clothes and which ones are strapping up their helmets.

On a recent edition of “Stokley and Evans, with Mark Schlereth” on 104.3 The Fan, Brandon Stokley and fill-in host Will Petersen found themselves on opposite sides of a debate that has divided coaching staffs and fan bases for as long as the preseason has existed. The question is simple. The answer, apparently, is not.

Petersen came out swinging by throwing Stokley’s own words back at him.

“You love to say, ‘You can’t live in your fears.’ Every time I’m on this show with you. ‘You can’t live in your fears; you can’t live in your fears.’ You want to put them all in bubble wrap!” Petersen said.

Stokley didn’t flinch.

“This game,” Stokley said.

“Why?” Petersen asked.

“You have gotten enough accomplished already,” Stokley said.

Petersen wasn’t buying it, and he had the receipts from last week’s loss to back it up.

“Have they? They got their asses kicked by the Packers,” Petersen said.

“Not offensively,” Stokley countered.

“Defensively they did,” Petersen fired back.

That’s where the argument found its real footing. The 33-13 loss to Green Bay left a mark, particularly on the defensive side. Vance Joseph publicly called his unit unengaged and lazy, the kind of language a coordinator doesn’t use unless the message needs to be loud and unmistakable.

Stokley, however, saw that critique as the coaching point itself, not a reason to run the starters back out for another preseason game.

“Right, and I think that’s a good thing. This defense has been together, what is a game gonna — so you wanna play all those? You wanna play Pat Surtain?” Stokley said.

Petersen didn’t back down.

“Yeah, I think you wanna go into the regular season with a much better taste in your mouth, and not your defensive coordinator calling you unengaged and lazy,” Petersen said.

Stokley pressed him on the full implication.

“So you wanna play Surtain? You wanna play them all?” Stokley asked.

Petersen delivered his answer with the kind of clarity that leaves no room for misinterpretation.

“I would play them all. And I would say, ‘Go get a three-and-out and I’ll get you off the field,'” Petersen said.

That’s a compelling middle ground. Not a full quarter. Not a half. One defensive series. Three plays. Force a punt. Walk off the field with the taste of a stop in your mouth instead of the lingering aftertaste of the Packers debacle. It gives the defense a chance to reset its confidence without exposing the starters to the kind of extended workload that creates injury risk two weeks before the Monday Night Football opener in Kansas City.

Stokley’s position is rooted in caution. Petersen’s is rooted in pride. Both are defensible. Both carry real consequences. The Broncos have two weeks until they step into Arrowhead against a returning Patrick Mahomes. Whether they spend Friday night resting or competing may not change the outcome of that game. But it will reveal something about the mentality this team carries into the most important stretch of its season.

Related

Broncos face decisions galore as preseason ends, cutdown nearsNo more Coach Peyton, as the Pro Bowl is going away for goodThere’s still a battle for the Broncos backup QB positionBroncos introduce two-foot hot dog to feed familiesSean Payton says Broncos QB Bo Nix ‘probably won’t play’ against VikingsReport: Broncos cut safety Taylor Rapp after only six days on the roster