DENVER BRONCOS

Peyton Manning says J.J. McCarthy didn’t respond to his text

Apr 23, 2024, 1:35 PM | Updated: Apr 24, 2024, 10:42 am

What if Peyton Manning texted you? Would you think it was for real or a prank? Maybe you would think it was like one of those political texts from a former president.

At 21 years old Michigan quarterback prospect J.J. McCarthy got a text from NFL Hall of Famer “Peyton Manning.” Except it really was the former star quarterback of the Denver Broncos and the youngster just didn’t believe it.

“I texted him the day after the national championship, I never met him but we invited him to our football camp and (Jim) Harbaugh wouldn’t let him miss a workout so he didn’t get to go. So I just reached out and said, ‘Hey, man, congratulations, wish you the best of luck in your next chapter,'” Manning said on 104.3 The Fan’s Stokley and Josh. “I guess he thought it was a prank, he never called me back so I texted him Monday from the same number.  And he’s like, ‘Oh, it really is you, Yeah, I thought that somebody was pranking me.’ And so I just kind of wished him luck and he asked me some questions. So he called me back and he was impressive to talk to.”

Manning led Tennesee to Citrus Bowl wins and a Gator Bowl victory while in college before going first overall in the 1998 NFL Draft to the Colts. McCarthy had more team success at Michigan than Manning did for the Volunteers, leading the Wolverines to a national title this winter.

McCarthy wasn’t eye-popping in that game, completing 10-18 passes for 140 yards and zero touchdowns. He didn’t throw an interception, but the ground game carried the Wolverines with four total touchdowns. On the season, McCarthy threw for nearly 3,000 yards to go along with 22 TDs and just four picks. Michigan finished a perfect 15-0. He only finished 10th in Heisman voting, to Manning’s second-place finish in 1997.

Stil it seems as though the two have struck up a little relationship, and perhaps it will continue with a chance of McCarthy being selected to where Manning lives—Denver

“I know Denver is very interested in him and it sounded like a place he’d love to come to but it’s a little bit out of his control,” Manning told Denver Sports over the air.

Denver is no longer the favorite to get McCarthy with the cycle pushing the Michigan man up boards the closer we’ve gotten to Thursday’s first round. ESPN wrote on Tuesday that Bo Nix may be the guy for Denver at No. 12.

Denver Broncos

Shedeur Sanders attends the quarterfinal game of the Emirates NBA Cup between the New York Knicks a...

Jake Shapiro

Shedeur Sanders not focused on going No. 1, has other ideas

Shedeur Sanders might be the best quarterback in his class but the odds of him going first in the NFL Draft have been slipping since the college football season ended

3 hours ago

Ashton Jeanty Broncos draft...

Will Petersen

Another ESPN mock draft has Broncos landing Ashton Jeanty

Like his colleague Mel Kiper Jr. did last month, ESPN's Field Yates thinks Ashton Jeanty could fall to the Broncos at No. 20 overall

5 hours ago

Maxx Crosby Russell Wilson...

Andrew Mason

NFL insider: ‘It’s possible’ Russell Wilson could be back in the AFC West

Russell Wilson, back in the AFC West? Longtime NFL insider Mike Sando of The Athletic says this could be in the cards, pointing to a possible reunion with new Raiders coach Pete Carroll.

7 hours ago

Sean Payton Andy Reid Broncos Bills Chiefs...

Will Petersen

Broncos’ goal should now be winning the AFC West in 2025

The Broncos winning the division was never realistic in the middle of a K.C. dynasty, but that's coming to a close, and Denver's window is just opening

14 hours ago

Bo Nix...

Andrew Mason

Is Bo Nix already pushing toward one of the top two QB tiers? One prominent national analyst says yes

Is Bo Nix approaching the second tier of NFL quarterbacks? One prominent national analyst, Fox Sports and NFL Network's Peter Schrager, says he is.

23 hours ago

Jonathon Cooper...

Jake Shapiro

Broncos could open season in Philly against Super Bowl champs

The Philadelphia Eagles are slated to host eight games in the fall of 2025 which means the Denver Broncos could be playing in the league's first game of the year

1 day ago

Peyton Manning says J.J. McCarthy didn’t respond to his text